Growing Pains: Why a Healthy Church Family Handles Conflict Well

There is something exciting about watching a church grow. New faces walk through the doors. New friendships form. New people step up to serve. New ideas surface, new ministries take shape, and more hands are willing to help carry the load. Growth is one of the great joys of church life.
But there is another side of growth that we probably do not talk about enough: growth brings growing pains.
More People, More Personalities
The more people you have, the more personalities you have. Some people are planners, while others are spontaneous. Some like to take charge, while others are perfectly happy working quietly in the background. Some want detailed instructions, while others see something that needs to be done and jump in immediately. Some are very direct, while others are sensitive to the way things are said.
None of those things make someone right or wrong. They simply make us different. And when different people work together, intentions sometimes get misunderstood.
Someone may genuinely believe they are helping while another person feels pushed aside. Someone may offer a suggestion intending it as encouragement, and the other person hears criticism instead. Someone may be unusually quiet one day, and another person assumes they are angry. Someone may forget to include somebody in a conversation, and suddenly the thought creeps in: I guess they don’t want me around.
What we believe happened and what the other person intended are sometimes two completely different things. That is where we have to be careful.
Resist Assigning Motives
One of the easiest things to do is assign motives to someone without ever asking what they meant.
“She obviously doesn’t respect me.” “He thinks he knows everything.” “They don’t want me involved.” “She was trying to take over.”
Maybe. Or maybe they were simply trying to help, or they were distracted, or they communicated poorly, or they never realized how their actions looked from the other side. And sometimes, yes, someone really does step on our toes. We are human, and it happens. There will be times when we have a legitimate reason to be frustrated, but even when our frustration is justified, our reaction may not be.
James 1:19 says, “Know this, my beloved brothers: let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger.” That is good advice for any family, and a church really is a family.
The Mark of a Healthy Family
Families irritate each other. They misunderstand one another, say things the wrong way, and get defensive. Sometimes somebody has a bad day and responds in a way they later regret. What makes a healthy family is not the absence of those moments. It is what happens afterward.
Healthy people talk. Healthy people apologize when they are wrong. Healthy people forgive. Healthy people refuse to let a five-minute misunderstanding turn into a five-year grudge.
Colossians 3:13 tells us to go on “bearing with one another and, if one has a complaint against another, forgiving each other; as the Lord has forgiven you, so you also must forgive.” I love that phrase, bearing with one another. The Bible apparently assumes that sometimes we are going to have to put up with each other, and that should probably make all of us smile a little.
Church unity does not mean everyone thinks alike, works alike, communicates alike, or shares the same personality. Unity means that despite those differences, we remember what brought us together in the first place: Jesus. That has to remain bigger than the misunderstanding.
Someone Is Always Watching
Here is something worth sitting with as our church continues to grow: not everyone walking through our doors already knows Jesus. Some are new to faith, still deciding what they believe, still watching to see whether any of this is real. And one of the things they are watching most closely is how we treat each other when we disagree.
A visitor may not remember the sermon title from their first Sunday with us, but they will remember whether they saw grace or grudges when two members bumped heads over a decision. They will remember whether an apology happened or whether the silence lingered for weeks. They will remember whether we looked like a family that loves each other through hard moments, or like just another group of people who happen to sit in the same room on Sundays.
How we handle conflict is not a side issue. It is part of our witness. A watching world, and a watching new believer, learns as much about the gospel from our reconciliation as they do from our worship.
What Growth Should Look Like Among Us
As a church grows, there will be more opportunities for things to get crossed up. More volunteers means more opinions. More ministries mean more decisions. More people means more chances for somebody to unintentionally step on somebody else’s toes. We should expect that. What we cannot afford to do is allow small moments to become large divisions.
Sometimes the best thing we can do is ask a simple question: “Hey, I may have taken that the wrong way. What did you mean?” That one conversation can prevent days of hurt feelings.
We also need to give each other the benefit of the doubt. If someone has consistently shown that they love the church, love people, and want to serve Jesus, our first assumption should not be that they suddenly decided to hurt us. And when someone realizes they handled something poorly and apologizes, we need to make room for grace. None of us wants to live in a church where one bad moment defines us forever. We all need forgiveness. We all need patience. We all need people who will occasionally say, “You know what? I know your heart. We’re okay.”
As we continue growing, here is what I hope becomes part of who we are: leaders who welcome help, and helpers who respect leadership. People who communicate instead of assuming. People who apologize quickly and forgive quickly. People who keep the mission bigger than the misunderstanding.
Because there are people around us who need hope. There are people who need encouragement. There are people who need to know Jesus, and some of them are watching us right now to see if any of this is real. That mission is far too important for us to become distracted by every personality difference, misunderstood comment, hurt feeling, or moment of frustration.
Growing pains are not necessarily a sign that something is wrong. Sometimes they are simply a sign that we are growing. And if we keep showing each other grace along the way, those growing pains can become the very thing that makes us a stronger church family, and a more credible witness to everyone watching.
Discover more from Scott A Marshall
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
